I/we just started watching this from the beginning again and still find it such a compelling show. It is so very frustrating to find some truly great television, and have the show cancelled – in most opinions – very prematurely.
Prodigal Son is one such show – and has many fans pushing hard to either bring it back into production full-time, or at least close things out properly with a mini-series or movie.
Here is IMdB’s official description of the show:
Malcolm Bright, one of the best criminal psychologists around, uses his twisted genius to help the NYPD solve crimes.
This doesn’t sound all that exciting but, man, IMHO, this show had so much going for it. Deep, thought-provoking stories. As a crime drama, most of the given types of stories, but worked through in a very unique way. Malcolm has severe PTSD and all the horrors that go with it. This is explored and used by the show – and done very well. The team around Malcolm learn how to work with his issues so those issues can work for them.
Aside from the whatever the given story is in each episode, there are underlying strings and stories and complications. All of these currents are woven into the episodes as appropriate and bring out a depth a lot of crime dramas don’t have.
The writing is excellent. Humor is infused into tense situations (as real people tend to do). Dialog doesn’t drag and you definitely get caught up in the story. Some really good camera work that cradles the dialog and scenery/sets.
What really does it for me with this show though, is the acting. Absolutely stellar acting all the way around.
Tom Payne (who I had only recently ‘discovered’ as Paul “Jesus” Rovia in The Walking Dead) is mind-blowing as Malcolm Bright. So expressive – even when not speaking. So tortured and yet so willing to do whatever it takes to solve the problem at hand.
Lou Diamond Phillips (a favorite of mine for MANY years and why I wanted to track this show down in the first place) nails the older boss/mentor to Bright that knows so many of his secrets. They gave Gil a ‘look’ and he carries it off beautifully. Absolutely loved his character in Longmire, but that is another whole post.
Michael Sheen is so amazingly creepy yet likeable as Malcolm’s father Martin. In many ways he is as much the protagonist in this show as Malcolm. (I don’t want to say too much for those who haven’t watched.
The supporting cast is just as brilliant. It’s a diverse cast that plays together, and off each other, so well. Truly a joy to watch.
Aurora Perrineau as Det. Dani Powell is smart and fun and is the one who really tries to work with Bright and his issues.
Frank Harts as det. JT Tarmel – such a great character. Great development over two seasons.
Bellamy Young as Malcolm’s mom, Jessica. Talk about a character with baggage. She carries it off great and has made me want to look up more of her work. (In writing this I found she was actually in “The Night Stalker” with LDP – cool).
Halston Sage as Ainsley Whitly, Malcolm’s sister. Not a huge fan of the character, but Halston does a really good job of bringing out all these facets of a very complicated person.
Keiko Agena as the quirky coroner Dr. Edrisa Tanaka. It had to be a really fun roll to do because she is very important to many of the story lines, yet her character gets to have a lot of fun.
Back to why I’m writing. The show was cancelled after only two seasons. Criminal in my opinion. Yes, they lost one of the main characters – but there was SO much more to explore. Personal relationships between the characters, the path individual characters found themselves on at that critical juncture, the new reality with that character gone. Of course, there will always be major crimes and murders so the vehicle is still there.
LDP and Tom have both said they’d be happy to continue with the characters. I really hope another network picks up this show and runs with it. From what I’ve seen on social media, there is a very dedicated fandom out there that desperately wants it back. It’s just such a shame to waste the potential – this might have been another ‘crime drama’ but it was new and unique rather than a ‘re-make’ of an older show.
If you haven’t seen this show and enjoy good drama / crime drama that is a great vehicle for in-depth discussions about a variety of topics – I highly recommend you track this show down and watch it. Join the Prodigals to #SaveProdigalSon !